Late yesterday, I received engineering and drainage plans for the new development north of Elm Grove called Woodridge Village. They show that the developer had planned detention that was not yet installed when last week’s heavy rains hit. This helps explain why water overflowed into the streets of Elm Grove and North Kingwood Forest instead of staying on the developer’s land – where it should have been – until it could be released at a controlled rate into Taylor Gully.
Figure Four Partners, LTD, a subsidiary of PSWA Inc. and Perry Homes, is the developer of approximately 262 acres. Rebel Contractors completely clear cut the entire area before building required – and as it turns out, crucial – stormwater detention.
Plans Differ from Execution
Plans clearly show a huge detention/retention pond that should have been in the southeast part of the property near Elm Grove and North Kingwood Forest. Its purpose: to capture runoff from the north and west. The plans also show a diversion of water from the existing ditch that borders the eastern side of the property into the non-existent detention pond.
This isn’t the only detention missing on the property. The northwest pond is also non-existent at this writing.
Here’s how the drainage works for the entire development.
Note that the direction of flow is generally from north to south and west to east.
Here’s a close-up of the area where a large concrete detention pond should have been. See red circle.
Not-yet-constructed detention pond was designed to capture water from the north and release it through a culvert into Taylor Gully.Approximate area for detention pond was 2 acres. Plans show pond was intended to be 15 feet deep. Thus, this one pond could have and should have retained approximately 30-acre feet of runoff, much of which wound up in the streets of Elm Grove.
Storm Hits Approximately Six Months after Clearcutting
Here’s what the area of the not-yet-constructed detention pond looked like after the storm.
Looking southwest toward the culvert. Abel Vera’s home is just beyond the tallest tree on the left. He and his neighbors up and down Village Springs suffered extensive damage from the water that was not retained on this site.
Below is what it looks like from the opposite direction, when you stand with your back to Elm Grove and Vera’s home.
According to the plans, almost everything between the camera position and the telephone poles in the background should be a 15-foot deep detention pond.
This discovery raises a question. Why did developers wait so long to install the proper detention? Satellite images from Google Earth show that this portion of the site was cleared sometime between 10/28/17 and 12/22/18. Residents say it was substantially cleared by November of 2018.
Developer’s Own Plans Contradict Its Statements
That means it sat clearcut without the required detention for about six months.
Figure Four’s statement also said the rainfall was as so intense that it should be called an Act of God. Harris County Flood Control later released a statement saying the rainfall was between a two and 50-year event.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/15/2019, with a heads-up from Jeff Miller
524 Days since Hurricane Harvey
Thoughts and conclusions expressed in this post of my opinions on matters of public policy and safety. They are protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and the Anti-SLAPP statutes of the Great State of Texas.
https://i0.wp.com/reduceflooding.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/CloseUp-Drainage.jpg?fit=1500%2C857&ssl=18571500adminadmin2019-05-15 13:28:252019-05-15 17:56:40Engineering Diagrams for Woodridge Development Reveal Crucial Detention Not Installed Before Elm Grove Flood
Below are several links that allow you to download the engineering plans for Woodridge Village, sections one and two. I haven’t had time to read them yet. Frankly they make my eyeballs bleed. But maybe some younger eyes can help.
I’m posting these because Kingwood is full of engineers who are more qualified to evaluate them than I. All of us are smarter than one of us.
I would love to hear from civil engineers who know about these things. Reply in confidence through the contact form on this web site.
A shout-out to Houston City Council Member Dave Martin and his staff for supplying these documents. And another to Montgomery County for supplying them to him.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/15/2019
624 Days since Hurricane Harvey
https://i0.wp.com/reduceflooding.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/Woodridge-Plans.jpg?fit=1500%2C1017&ssl=110171500adminadmin2019-05-14 23:18:012019-05-14 23:18:33Engineering Plans for Figure Four Development Near Elm Grove
The Webster and Spurlock law firms today jointly filed a lawsuit on behalf of more than one hundred flooded home owners in the Elm Grove area. Webster and Spurlock list Figure Four Partners, LTD., PSWA, Inc., and Rebel Contractors, Inc. as the defendants.
Details of Suit
The lawyers say they may amend the suit to add Perry Homes and LJA Engineers. In addition, they say more homeowners could soon join the suit. Elm Grove Homeowners Association reportedly held another meeting with the lawyers at Good Shepherd Episcopal Church tonight.
The suit alleges negligence, negligence per se, gross negligence, nuisance, and violation of Section 11.086 of the Texas Water Code. Plaintiffs see exemplary damages and a permanent injunction among other things.
Also, videos and photographs that have surfaced since the flood show water pouring out of their new development into the streets of Elm Grove that already were retaining rain. Elsewhere in Kingwood, there was little street flooding that entered homes. So it appears that the combination of sheet flow from Figure Fours’ development with street flooding made the difference.
One resident sent me these pictures last night via the submissions page on this web site. They show water in the streets that appears to be higher than water in Taylor Gully.
Taylor Gulley just before the flood peaked, according to the photographer. Image taken at Rustling Elms shows that ditch was mostly within its banks at this point, though certainly, some overflow can be seen.Water over bumper of school bus.Never park your car in the street during a flash flood.Same scene from lower angle a little later in the flood.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/14/2019
623 Days since Hurricane Harvey
https://i0.wp.com/reduceflooding.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/05/SchoolBus.jpg?fit=1500%2C1689&ssl=116891500adminadmin2019-05-14 21:48:422019-05-14 21:52:01Webster, Spurlock Law Firms File Suit on Behalf of More Than 100 Flood Victims
Engineering Diagrams for Woodridge Development Reveal Crucial Detention Not Installed Before Elm Grove Flood
Late yesterday, I received engineering and drainage plans for the new development north of Elm Grove called Woodridge Village. They show that the developer had planned detention that was not yet installed when last week’s heavy rains hit. This helps explain why water overflowed into the streets of Elm Grove and North Kingwood Forest instead of staying on the developer’s land – where it should have been – until it could be released at a controlled rate into Taylor Gully.
Figure Four Partners, LTD, a subsidiary of PSWA Inc. and Perry Homes, is the developer of approximately 262 acres. Rebel Contractors completely clear cut the entire area before building required – and as it turns out, crucial – stormwater detention.
Plans Differ from Execution
Plans clearly show a huge detention/retention pond that should have been in the southeast part of the property near Elm Grove and North Kingwood Forest. Its purpose: to capture runoff from the north and west. The plans also show a diversion of water from the existing ditch that borders the eastern side of the property into the non-existent detention pond.
This isn’t the only detention missing on the property. The northwest pond is also non-existent at this writing.
Photographs taken last week after the rains show that the southwest ditch overflowed where it narrowed down into a two foot pipe. Water then rushed overland into North Kingwood Forest on the east side and Elm Grove on the west. Where the detention pond should have been, one could see large erosion channels approximately one to four feet deep.
Here’s how the drainage works for the entire development.
Here’s a close-up of the area where a large concrete detention pond should have been. See red circle.
Storm Hits Approximately Six Months after Clearcutting
Here’s what the area of the not-yet-constructed detention pond looked like after the storm.
Below is what it looks like from the opposite direction, when you stand with your back to Elm Grove and Vera’s home.
This discovery raises a question. Why did developers wait so long to install the proper detention? Satellite images from Google Earth show that this portion of the site was cleared sometime between 10/28/17 and 12/22/18. Residents say it was substantially cleared by November of 2018.
Developer’s Own Plans Contradict Its Statements
Figure Four Partners, LTD said in a statement released after the flood that their detention was installed AND that it functioned as planned. Figure Four’s own plans and these photos tell a different story.
Figure Four’s statement also said the rainfall was as so intense that it should be called an Act of God. Harris County Flood Control later released a statement saying the rainfall was between a two and 50-year event.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/15/2019, with a heads-up from Jeff Miller
524 Days since Hurricane Harvey
Thoughts and conclusions expressed in this post of my opinions on matters of public policy and safety. They are protected by the First Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and the Anti-SLAPP statutes of the Great State of Texas.
Engineering Plans for Figure Four Development Near Elm Grove
Below are several links that allow you to download the engineering plans for Woodridge Village, sections one and two. I haven’t had time to read them yet. Frankly they make my eyeballs bleed. But maybe some younger eyes can help.
I’m posting these because Kingwood is full of engineers who are more qualified to evaluate them than I. All of us are smarter than one of us.
Woodridge Village, Sections One and Two, comprise those huge clearcut areas north of Elm Grove. During heavy rains last week, video shows water pouring out of the newly clearcut section into Elm Grove. Something appears to have gone wrong. Texas law prohibits flooding your neighbors.
Please Help Review Engineering Plans
The first talks about their constructions plans for Waterline Relocation and Detention Ponds.
The second talks about their Water, Sanitary Sewer and Drainage Facilities & Paving and Appurtenances for Section 1 of the development.
The third talks about their Water, Sanitary Sewer and Drainage Facilities & Paving and Appurtenances for Section 2 of the development.
I would love to hear from civil engineers who know about these things. Reply in confidence through the contact form on this web site.
A shout-out to Houston City Council Member Dave Martin and his staff for supplying these documents. And another to Montgomery County for supplying them to him.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/15/2019
624 Days since Hurricane Harvey
Webster, Spurlock Law Firms File Suit on Behalf of More Than 100 Flood Victims
The Webster and Spurlock law firms today jointly filed a lawsuit on behalf of more than one hundred flooded home owners in the Elm Grove area. Webster and Spurlock list Figure Four Partners, LTD., PSWA, Inc., and Rebel Contractors, Inc. as the defendants.
Details of Suit
The lawyers say they may amend the suit to add Perry Homes and LJA Engineers. In addition, they say more homeowners could soon join the suit. Elm Grove Homeowners Association reportedly held another meeting with the lawyers at Good Shepherd Episcopal Church tonight.
The suit alleges negligence, negligence per se, gross negligence, nuisance, and violation of Section 11.086 of the Texas Water Code. Plaintiffs see exemplary damages and a permanent injunction among other things.
Read the text of the their legal filing here.
A statement by Figure Four Partners, LTD, claims the flood was an act of God. However, 93% of all the homes that flooded in Kingwood and Forest Cove were within a few flocks of the land that Figure Four clearcut.
Background
Also, videos and photographs that have surfaced since the flood show water pouring out of their new development into the streets of Elm Grove that already were retaining rain. Elsewhere in Kingwood, there was little street flooding that entered homes. So it appears that the combination of sheet flow from Figure Fours’ development with street flooding made the difference.
One resident sent me these pictures last night via the submissions page on this web site. They show water in the streets that appears to be higher than water in Taylor Gully.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 5/14/2019
623 Days since Hurricane Harvey