Crenshaw on Obstacles to Public Policy Reform
11/17/26 – During a 2-hour interview with U.S. Rep. Dan Crenshaw of Congressional District Two, he discussed many topics, including his achievements during his eight years in office and how compromise has become a dirty word in politics. In my third post from that interview, I’ll relate his thoughts on other obstacles to public-policy reform. This has been edited for brevity.
Meaning of Election Outcome
Rehak: What did the outcome of this mid-term election signify?
Crenshaw: Subconsciously, the American public demands compromise because look what happens. In almost every single mid-term election in this century, the incumbent party of the President gets wiped out. There seems to be a subconscious desire by the American public to force compromise.
But you have to still allow some logical, nuanced, thoughtful, complicated policy discussions to then take place. And that’s what people and politics still don’t allow in many ways.
Complexity Creates Suspicion
Crenshaw: For instance, people ask “Why couldn’t you pass immigration law?” They get frustrated when I tell them how complicated immigration is. Why is it complicated? Let me just paint a picture for you.
Let’s start a country, you and me, okay? We have to think about how our border is going to be set up. Who’s going to control the border? Who do we let in? Who do we not let in? Does their age matter? Does it matter why they’re coming? Do you see how complicated that got just in a few seconds?
People get really mad because these bills are super long. I’m like, “Why does that make you mad?” I remember Elon Musk taking down an important bill because it was so long, despite the fact that it had really good reforms in it. That’s another example of “single-variable analysis,” where you look at one aspect of a problem in isolation, without considering causes, relationships, or dependencies with other aspects.
Here was one of the smartest, most successful guys in the world, publicly destroying a piece of legislation because it was over a thousand pages. I’m like, “Sorry! You mean the length of the bill is what makes it good or bad?”
That is the stupidest thing I can possibly imagine. But people hate long bills. They assume that we’re sneaking all these things in there, like some dark cabal. No! They’re just long!
Why We Have a Representative Republic
Rehak: Let’s drill down from the outcome to the process that created it. Help me understand it.
Crenshaw: Law is complicated and the legal language required is complicated. Plus policy requires research. When you start to analyze it, you come up with more changes. You also deal with the Executive Branch for what’s called “technical assistance.” The entire time, you’re getting more and more granular in the policy.
Then you actually give it to the lawyers. So, you go to Legislative Council, which is a whole other office in the Congress. And these are the lawyers that turn the policy into legal language.
It is literally like editing U.S. Code [a compilation of all federal statutes enacted by Congress]. Even if you think you know what the text is saying, chances are you don’t because of so many obscure references.
I could read a whole paper on biochemistry. But I don’t have the background to understand what it means. So, when you’re dealing with complicated policy issues, the reason we have this representative republic is because you’re entrusting a member of Congress to do that hard work for you, to understand those trade-offs.
Trustees Vs. Delegates
Rehak: In your opinion, what is a member of Congress supposed to be: a trustee or delegate?
Crenshaw: My answer is, of course, a trustee. You’re entrusting them to use their own judgment. Think of your doctor, accountant or lawyer.
People understand that. They regularly rely on the expertise of others. But for some reason, that same logic doesn’t apply to politics.
You could put every bill up for a public vote digitally and people could probably use AI and figure it out, but that would be insane, because there’s no way that the public would even be able to digest every single nuance of thousands of bills. That’s the whole point of having representatives who do it full time…for you.
The Long-Gone Days of the Citizen Legislator
Rehak: People have this sort of romantic idea of the citizen legislator.
Crenshaw: That was a great idea, like maybe in the 1700s, when things just weren’t very complicated. But now, you need professional legislators. You need people who truly seek to understand issues and who can forge consensus.
But even the most dedicated legislators can’t wrap their heads around every bill. That’s why you have different committees. You have to trust your colleagues to really know what they’re talking about when it comes to agricultural issues, for instance.
I studied a specific kind of health care because I’m on the Energy and Commerce Committee, which oversees Health and Human Services, Medicare, Medicaid, Affordable Health Care, the CDC, the FDA and more.
On another committee, I delve into national security, the CIA, intelligence, cartels and border issues. So, I’m not diving into financial reform on banks! Even for those of us who do this full time, you still have to specialize.
A Basic Civics Lesson
Rehak: That’s a basic civics lesson.
Crenshaw: Yes, this stuff is complicated.
You elect somebody whose basic values you agree with. And then you have to trust them to actually implement legislation consistent with those values and explain it to you.
You either like their explanation or you don’t.
But don’t elect somebody who’s just throwing red meat at you, which is what happens too often now. Because there is about a zero chance that they’re going to work on serious policy.
Rehak: Congressman, thank you for working so tirelessly for the people of this district for eight long years.
Crenshaw: That’s what I signed up for. It’s been great.
Posted by Bob Rehak on 11/16/26
3367 Days since Hurricane Harvey










