Legislative Goals Re: Sand Mining
- Establish a water quality district on the San Jacinto like the John Graves District on the Brazos.
- Key Provision #1: Moves mining outside the 100-year flood plain as permits come up for renewal.
- Why? Mining in floodway can accelerate sedimentation far above the natural rate. Sediment accumulations form dams that block river and contribute to flooding.
- Key Provision #2: Establishes performance bonds to ensure reclamation.
- Why? Some miners walk away from mines before reclamation, creating eyesores and safety hazards that discourage development in surrounding communities.
- Put teeth in TCEQ fines.
- Key Provision: Increases fines to the point where they actually discourage negative practices.
- Why? Current fines are slap on wrist. Average fine for last 7 years was about $800. Has not cleaned up industry.
- Bring best management practices for sand mining in Texas up to the standards in the rest of the country and the world.
- Key Provisions:
- Locate mines outside of floodways. (Most important)
- Establish performance bonds to cover the cost of cleanup.
- Increase the width of dikes.
- Decrease the slope of dikes.
- Control erosion with vegetation.
- Replant areas not actively being mined.
- Avoid clearing areas that will not soon be mined.
- Protect stockpiles from flooding.
- Mine only above the thalweg (deepest part of the river).
- Establish performance bonds to guarantee remediation of breaches and/or repurposing of mined areas once mining is complete
- Why? The practices where we lag the rest of the world caused the most damage during Harvey.
- Key Provisions:
Fact Sheets/Background
- Lake Houston Area Damages
- Improving Best Management Practices
- Dangers of River Mining
- River Migration, Pit Capture, and Erosion Hazard Zones
- John Graves District: A Model for the Future of the San Jacinto
- Importance of Vegetation in Reducing Erosion
- Is There Enough Sand Outside the Floodway?
- Underappraisal of Sand Mine Properties in Montgomery County
Legislation Introduced in 2021
HB4478: Reclamation and Performance Bonds
Dan Huberty from the Lake Houston Area introduced HB4478 which addresses abandonment of sand mines. Many miners simply walk away from mines leaving abandoned, rusting equipment in place and dangerous conditions. Huberty’s bill would require mines to file a reclamation plan before they start mining and also post a bond ensuring they actually execute the plan. Currently, mines are required to file a plan, but there is no requirement in Texas to execute it. Miners can simply walk away from mines after they extract the last ounce of sand. That can leave scars on the landscape, degrade water quality, and threaten public safety.
HB767: Best Practices
Huberty also introduced HB767, a bill that would require the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality to establish and publish best management practices for sand mining. However, it does not require sand mines to follow the practices. While that’s disappointing, it could bring heat to operations that don’t follow the guidelines. This bill has already been referred to the Environmental Regulation Committee where it died in the 2019 session.
HB4341: Changes Responsibility for Oversight
Representative Kyle Biederman from Fredericksburg introduced HB4341, a bill that would transfer regulation of aggregate production operations from the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) to the Texas Railroad Commission (TRRC). The bill gives the Railroad Commission the right to conduct unannounced inspections to ensure compliance with water and air quality regulations. Biederman’s bill also mandates reclamation of mines, but includes more specifics than Huberty’s. Finally, it provides criminal penalties for people who knowingly and willfully violate conditions of their permits. The big news: transfer of oversight responsibility from the TCEQ to TRRC. If it passes, it will be a resounding vote of “no confidence” in the job that the TCEQ has been doing in regulating sand mines.
HB2422: Limiting Location of Mines
Representative Erin Zwiener from Kyle introduced HB2422. Her bill applies to counties with a population of 500,000 or more. It would allow county commissioners to prohibit the construction or expansion of an aggregate production operation at a location less than one mile from a residence, school, place of worship, hospital, or land platted for residential development. The bill would also allow commissioners to establish conditions for the construction or expansion of mines elsewhere in the county.
HB291: Reclamation and Performance Bonds
Representative Andrew Murr from Kerrville introduced HB291. It also focuses on reclamation of mines. It would require the grading of banks, revegetation, and removal of equipment upon completion of mining. The bill would also require operators to reclaim mines in stages as extraction activities on different parts cease. It would give miners a deadline for reclamation, too: six months. Finally, it would require a performance bond equal to $2,500 for each acre affected by extraction activities. Upon completion of reclamation activities, the TCEQ would release the performance bond. Cities and counties would have the right to waive the reclamation requirement if reclamation conflicts with proposed future uses of the land.
HB1544: APO Taxation
Representative Ryan Guillen from Rio Grande City introduced HB1544. It addresses the tax classification of land used for sand mining. The language is confusing and an analysis of the bill has not yet been submitted. However, it appears to state that sand mine, once it meets requirements for reclamation, may revert to a property tax rate associated with open space, such as agriculture. The bill lays out some unique requirements for reclamation not discussed in the other bills here. While this seems to give sand miners a positive incentive to restore land, I’m not sure how much. In Montgomery County, the tax appraiser routinely grants ag exemptions to land used for sand mining.
HB1912/SB1209: Permit Requirements
HB1912 filed by Representative Terry Wilson of Georgetown establishes additional permit requirements for aggregate production operations. They affect air quality, light pollution, noise, blasting, dust, and other operational issues identified by the House Interim Committee on APOs back in January.
State Senator Charles Schwertner from Bryan introduced SB1209. It is an identical companion bill to HB1912. Companion bills increase the chance of passage by broadening the base of support in both houses.
Senator Creighton Introduces Bill that Could Speed Up Flood Planning, Mitigation
In the wake of Hurricane Harvey, many officials complained bitterly that money from the State’s “rainy day” fund couldn’t be used for flood mitigation projects. Former Harris County Judge Ed Emmett often said, “If Harvey wasn’t a rainy day, I don’t know what is!” Creighton Introduces Bill That Could Speed Flood Mitigation Responding to a […]
Two Dozen Pieces of Legislation Introduced to Help Prevent Another Disaster like Harvey
While I have primarily focused on legislation around sand mining, legislators in both the Texas House and Senate have filed bills that address other aspects of the Harvey disaster. I have arbitrarily grouped them into several categories below to make this rather lengthy list easier to follow. Preparedness Remember how residents received no warning to […]
Huberty Introduces HB1671 To Extend Water-Quality Protections to West Fork
State Representative Dan Huberty introduced House Bill 1671 this week. It amends Section 26.551 of the Water Code to give the West Fork of the San Jacinto protections enjoyed by the John Graves Scenic District on the Brazos as a result of a pilot program started in 2005. The bill covers the portion of the […]
Sand Miners Plan TACA Days in Austin for February 4th, 5th
Sand miners plan to gather in Austin on February 4th and 5th to meet with legislators for their annual TACA Days. TACA stands for the Texas Aggregate and Concrete Association. It represents sand miners. They hope to beat back regulation of the industry that could help protect areas like Lake Houston from excessive sedimentation. They […]
Three Baby Steps on Sand Mining Legislation
After Harvey, it became clear that the simplest and most effective way to avoid sedimentation due to sand mining, was to prevent any new sand mining in the floodway. State Representative Dan Huberty introduced three new bills to toughen legislation on sand mines yesterday. But these bills never mention words like river, setback, buffer zone, […]
First Proposal to Improve Sand-Mine Regulation in House
On December 11, 2018, Texas State Representative Terry Wilson introduced HB509. HB509 is a bill to regulate aggregate production operations (APOs). APOs include sand mines. HB509 Stipulates Consideration of Hydrologic Impact During Permitting Currently, sand mines in Texas are permitted and inspected by the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ). HB509 enables the Texas Railroad […]
How Sand Mines Increased Erosion Potential by 33X During Harvey
Yesterday, I posted about how major storms transport the vast majority of the sediment that flushes down rivers. That’s a major reason to have wide buffers between mines and rivers, and to get the mines out of the floodway. One major event, as we have seen, can alter a river and people’s lives forever. However, […]
99% Solutions to a 1% Problem Are No Solutions at All
Today, I read a scientific article that talked about 99% solutions to 1% problems. It hit me between the eyes with the force of a freight train. It was written 30 years before Hurricane Harvey for a 1987 symposium sponsored by the U.S. Navy called Sedimentation Control to Reduce Maintenance Dredging of Navigational Facilities in Estuaries. […]